Vacant Properties
Vacant Properties

Prevention and Early Intervention

The most effective way to address commercial vacancy and deterioration is to intervene before a property becomes chronically vacant, severely deteriorated, or difficult to return to productive use. Once a property has sat vacant for years, it may have deteriorated to the point where rehabilitation costs are prohibitively high, and the owner may have walked away. This decline harms neighboring businesses, the corridor, and the surrounding residential community. At that point, communities might need to rely on more time- and resource-intensive tools.

Local governments and their partners should work to understand why a property remains vacant, support owners who are willing to act, and address barriers to reinvestment. At the same time, they should monitor property conditions, establish clear maintenance expectations, and hold negligent or unresponsive owners accountable. This balanced approach can help prevent further deterioration and preserve opportunities for reuse before more intensive interventions become necessary.

LEARN MORE

Prefer a PDF? Download the full contents of the online resource library on commercial vacancy here: Revitalizing Commercial Corridors: A Guide to Public Strategies for Vacancy and Reuse.

Photo taken in St. Louis of a vacant two-story dark brick commercial building with decorative white brick patterns near the roofline. The upper windows are boarded up, and the boards over the ground-floor storefronts are painted with colorful abstract murals in blue, yellow, and red. Next door is an occupied brick storefront with an awning, and cars are parked along the street.
A vacant commercial property in St. Louis with boarded windows and a colorful abstract mural decorating the ground-floor storefronts. (Photo: Community Progress)

Incentives

Ideally, local governments can work in partnership with property owners to identify barriers to occupancy, prevent deterioration and vacancy, and connect owners with resources and support to keep properties in productive use without taking a heavy enforcement approach. Many tools described later (see Enabling Reuse)—including grants, loans, zoning updates, tenant-improvement assistance, permitting, corridor management, clean-and-safe programs, marketing, and activation—work best before a property becomes vacant or seriously deteriorated. Used early, they can help an owner make a critical repair, keep a business in place, fill a storefront before it sits empty, or address corridor conditions that drive customers and investment away.

Local governments should connect code enforcement with economic development staff and corridor partners, who are often the first to see warning signs. Working together, they can reach an owner or business while someone is still willing to act and the problem is still affordable to fix. The earlier a community intervenes, the more options it has.

Proactive Code Enforcement

Code enforcement is one of the most important public tools for keeping commercial properties safe, secure, and well maintained. By requiring owners to correct unsafe or deteriorating conditions, local governments can slow physical decline and protect neighboring businesses and property values. In weaker real estate markets, code enforcement must be balanced with incentive programs (see Enabling Reuse).

Nearly every code enforcement department has limited capacity, which is why a corridor strategy and a commitment to targeted public investment are critical. Rather than responding only to complaints, local governments can focus limited resources on priority commercial districts where coordinated public investments are already planned.

Our experience working with communities across the country suggests property maintenance code enforcement has traditionally focused on residential properties, with commercial buildings receiving less attention and fewer specialized resources. As a result, code enforcement staff are not always integrated into economic development or corridor revitalization efforts, despite their central role in working to improve property conditions.

Communities should evaluate whether their property maintenance, fire, building, and health codes are effective tools for addressing vacant and deteriorated commercial properties; whether code enforcement officers have the training and authority to handle commercial vacancy; and whether code enforcement, economic development, and legal staff coordinate well enough to pursue complex enforcement actions when voluntary compliance fails.

Treating code enforcement as a core part of commercial revitalization protects existing investments and creates the conditions for redevelopment.

Key Questions

Effectiveness of Tools

  • Can code enforcement issue property maintenance warnings and notices with clear correction deadlines?
  • Are fines and penalties proportionate to the scale, severity, and impact of violations—and sufficient to encourage compliance?
  • Can the municipality recover the cost of inspections, emergency repairs, securing, demolition, or other abatement activities? (See Nuisance Abatement)
  • Can unpaid fines, fees, and abatement costs be added to the property’s tax bill or collected as a lien? (See Code Lien Foreclosure)

Expertise and Capacity

  • Do code enforcement staff understand the unique challenges of commercial properties, such as code requirements, environmental concerns, and complex ownership structures?
  • Do they have the training and technical knowledge—including access to building, fire, environmental, and legal expertise—to document violations and build a strong enforcement case?
  • Is there enough staff capacity to follow cases from inspection to compliance or enforcement action?

Coordination

  • Do code enforcement, economic development, planning, legal, tax, finance, and other relevant departments coordinate on problem commercial properties?
  • Is there a clear process for escalation when voluntary compliance fails?
  • Can legal counsel support complex enforcement actions?

Vacant Property Registries

Vacant property registries, or vacant property registration ordinances (VPROs), can help bring vacant properties into compliance with local property maintenance codes. Most states give local governments broad discretion to adopt and craft such ordinances, but authority varies by state law.

VPROs typically require owners of vacant properties to register with the local government by providing specific contact information and paying a fee. Many also require owners to maintain the properties, for example by boarding windows or mowing the grass. VPROs can help focus a local government’s efforts on identifying and addressing vacant properties but must be seen as one piece of a larger strategic approach.

VPROs serve three core purposes:

  • Ensure that the local government knows who owns vacant properties and can reach them
  • Ensure owners understand their obligations under relevant codes and regulations
  • Motivate owners to meet minimum maintenance standards

A strong VPRO fee structure reflects the municipality’s costs of administering the VPRO program, which can include helping to offset unpaid abatement costs on vacant properties. This fee can also help to motivate owners to restore and reuse their properties.

A well-designed VPRO should include:

  • Clear definition of which properties and which parties must register
  • Registration requirements, including contact information for the owner or lienholder
  • A fee structure
  • Owner obligations, such as property maintenance and carrying liability insurance
  • Penalties for failing to register

Tying incentives to registration can make a VPRO more useful, for example by waiving registration fees or escalating them based on length of vacancy. Bangor, Maine, lets an owner request a temporary deferral of the registration fee when an active building permit is on file with the code enforcement office.

A registry is only as effective as the community’s capacity to administer and enforce it. Few owners will register vacant properties voluntarily, particularly when registration carries fees or maintenance requirements. Communities need a proactive process for identifying unregistered properties, keeping the registry accurate, and following up with owners who fail to register or maintain their properties.

Registration alone will not solve market challenges or make obsolete properties viable for reuse, and overly punitive approaches may not lead to reoccupancy. Communities should connect the registry to incentives or other redevelopment tools that help owners address property conditions and prepare them for reuse. This shifts the registry from a tracking list to an early intervention tool and pipeline for targeted assistance.

Business Licensing

Where VPROs aim to compel occupancy of vacant commercial properties, business licensing is a useful tool for occupied ones. Licensing and renewal are recurring opportunities to identify and address property conditions that undermine corridors. Where state and local law allows, municipalities can condition license issuance or renewal on compliance, use provisional licenses tied to corrective-action plans, and escalate consequences for chronic violations.

At the same time, licensing requirements can unintentionally make it harder to reoccupy vacant space. Lengthy processes, duplicative requirements, or requirements that do not reflect a property’s condition and intended use add time and cost for businesses trying to open or reactivate space.

Communities should assess whether their licensing and permitting processes fit local market and building conditions.

Key Questions

  • Are licensing and permitting requirements proportional to a property’s use and condition, or could they be streamlined to cut unnecessary time and costs while still protecting health and safety?
  • Can business licensing be used as an enforcement tool? For example, can it condition issuance or renewal on compliance or use provisional licenses tied to corrective-action plans?
  • Are there meaningful consequences for chronic violations?