Addressing Commercial Property Vacancy and Deterioration
LEARN MORE
Prefer a PDF? Download the full contents of the online resource library on commercial vacancy here: Revitalizing Commercial Corridors: A Guide to Public Strategies for Vacancy and Reuse.
Neighborhood commercial corridors provide essential goods and services, support local businesses and jobs, generate tax revenue, and serve as gathering places that contribute to neighborhood identity and quality of life. Yet many corridors face persistent vacancy, deteriorating properties, and declining investment as economic shifts, changing consumer behavior, population loss, and other forces reshape demand for commercial space.
Local governments have a role to play in addressing these challenges by developing strategies and coordinating tools for intervention, as opposed to waiting for the market to recover. The central challenge for local governments is not simply how to fill vacant buildings, but how to shape the future of commercial corridors so they remain assets to the communities they serve.
Local governments and their partners should move from reactive, property-by-property interventions toward coordinated strategies for commercial corridor revitalization. In this section of our online resource guide, we focus on small-scale, neighborhood-serving commercial properties—including storefronts, mixed-use buildings, and neighborhood shopping centers—and provides a framework for understanding local conditions, setting a vision, and selecting public tools that advance community priorities.
Understanding Today’s Neighborhood Commercial Corridors
Commercial corridors play a critical role in neighborhood vitality and health. They provide essential goods and services, create jobs, generate tax revenue, support local entrepreneurship, and contribute to a community’s identity and sense of place.
Beyond their economic function, commercial corridors have historically served as the social infrastructure of neighborhoods by providing gathering spaces, “third places” outside of home and work, and opportunities for connection and community building.
While commercial corridors were once the center of neighborhood activity, their role has changed. Over the past several decades, shifts in how we live, work, and spend money have fundamentally altered the landscape of neighborhood retail and commercial activity. The growth of e-commerce, changes in consumer preferences, suburban development, remote work, and evolving demographics have reshaped demand for traditional commercial spaces.
Many corridors designed for a different era no longer align with current market conditions or community needs, with some experiencing widespread vacancy. Communities must move beyond addressing single properties and instead develop strategies that respond to today’s market realities, build on local assets, and position commercial corridors for their next chapter.
Much of the national conversation surrounding commercial vacancy since the COVID-19 pandemic has focused on the challenges facing downtown office markets. Headlines have centered on declining office occupancy, remote work, falling property values, and the resulting fiscal impact on major cities. These issues are significant, but they represent only one segment of the commercial real estate landscape.
This guide focuses instead on small-scale, neighborhood-serving commercial properties—the storefronts, mixed-use buildings, neighborhood shopping centers, and traditional commercial corridors that residents encounter in their daily lives. They are often along main streets, commercial avenues, and neighborhood business districts. They house local retailers, restaurants, service providers, professional offices, and community institutions that contribute to neighborhood identity and quality of life.
Commercial vacancy challenges look different depending on local context. Smaller rural communities that have experienced population loss may have difficulty attracting and retaining essential businesses. Historically Black communities continue to experience the impacts of decades of discriminatory land use policies, disinvestment, urban renewal, and the displacement of Black-owned businesses and community institutions. Even affluent communities are grappling with changing retail markets and persistent vacancies due to aging infrastructure, obsolete buildings, and changes in consumer demand.
Vacant and deteriorating commercial spaces are symptoms of deeper economic and social changes. In some communities, underperforming commercial corridors are where broader challenges—housing instability, public safety concerns, substance use, and other impacts of concentrated disinvestment—are most visible. These conditions reinforce the need for communities to think critically about the future of their commercial properties and identify interventions that reflect current realities.
Commercial vacancy and deterioration exist along a spectrum of occupancy and physical conditions that must be understood at the parcel level (see Understand Parcel Conditions). The national field of practice, local jurisdictions, policies, and programs use a variety of terms to describe these conditions. These terms are often intertwined with both structures and land. For clarity and conciseness, this guide uses “commercial vacancy and deterioration” as an umbrella term encompassing the range of occupancy status and conditions identified in the table below, unless otherwise noted.
The Problem Is More Than Vacancy: Occupancy Status and Condition
| Occupancy Status: How is the owner using it? | |
|---|---|
| Underutilized | The owner is using the property below its potential, such as leaving upper floors vacant, holding excess space, or using it primarily for parking or storage. |
| Vacant | The owner has shown willingness or interest in reoccupancy, though has not been motivated to act. |
| Abandoned | The property has been vacant for several years, and the owner has shown little to no investment in maintaining it or returning it to productive use. |
| Physical Condition: What shape is it in? | |
|---|---|
| Marketable | Appears suitable for occupancy or reuse with minimal repairs or improvements. |
| Deteriorated | Shows signs of deferred maintenance or physical decline, whether occupied or vacant. |
| Structurally Unsound | Significant structural deficiencies that may compromise safety or require substantial rehabilitation. |
| Obsolete | No longer meets its original purpose or current market, functional, or code requirements without significant adaptation. |
Source: Community Progress, Revitalizing Commercial Corridors: A Guide to Public Strategies for Vacancy and Reuse.
The Costs of Inaction
Addressing commercial vacancy is complex, requiring coordination with property owners, businesses, residents, developers, local governments, and other partners. It also requires investments in buildings, infrastructure, public spaces, business support, and market development. But letting these complexities delay intervention can make the challenge harder to solve and more expensive over time. Long-term vacancy can lead to deferred maintenance and disinvestment that spreads to surrounding blocks, particularly where demand is already weak or the area has a history of disinvestment. Communities must move beyond the assumption that the market will eventually resolve vacancy on its own. Vacant properties beget larger challenges.
The long-term cost of doing nothing about vacancy and deterioration often exceeds the cost of strategic intervention. Local governments and their partners have tools and strategies to support reinvestment in commercial corridors. The right intervention will vary based on local market conditions and the underlying causes of vacancy.
There is no arguing that commercial corridors matter for a neighborhood’s long-term vitality. The charge for each community is to determine what future role disinvested and underperforming (or even totally abandoned) corridors can play, and what public intervention and partnerships can realistically support.
Evolving the Vacancy Field to Address Commercial Properties
Over the past 15 years, communities have built effective tools for addressing vacant, abandoned, and deteriorated properties, including land banks, strategic code enforcement practices, and efficient delinquent property tax enforcement systems. These tools were designed largely for residential properties, and communities should not assume they will work the same way for commercial ones. Owners of distressed commercial properties often stay current on taxes, making tax foreclosure a less viable intervention point. Meanwhile, rehabilitation costs can exceed market value, and environmental contamination increases risk and raises the cost of acquisition.
The lesson from residential property revitalization still holds, however. The market alone will not solve the most difficult properties. Meeting this challenge requires continued investment in real estate and redevelopment expertise, alongside stronger coordination across local government departments.
The work should be guided by a vision for the corridor: Should it be the neighborhood hub for cultural experiences, a restaurant or retail destination, a centralized location for health and other social services, green infrastructure with trees and bioswales, or something completely different? This guide provides local governments and their partners with the information needed to assess the status of commercial corridors, develop a strategy based on a future vision, and leverage tools and partnerships to ensure they are contributing to healthy, equitable communities.