Compelling Compliance or Transfer
IN THIS SECTION
The goal of prevention and early intervention is to reduce the need for more expensive public intervention down the line. However, when property owners fail to address persistent problems, or when private ownership can no longer achieve community goals, local governments may need to take a more active enforcement role. That can mean using tools that compel owners to address property conditions and seek reoccupancy or, ultimately, tools that facilitate the transfer of properties to new, responsible ownership.
LEARN MORE
Prefer a PDF? Download the full contents of the online resource library on commercial vacancy here: Revitalizing Commercial Corridors: A Guide to Public Strategies for Vacancy and Reuse.
Nuisance Abatement
Unsecured buildings, illegal dumping, overgrown grass, or other persistent nuisances affect more than the individual property where they occur. Concentrated along a corridor, they discourage customers, hurt neighboring businesses, reduce property values, and undermine confidence in the area. Nuisance abatement is an important tool for protecting the health, safety, and vitality of commercial corridors, and it works best as part of proactive code enforcement efforts. Nuisance abatement is the process by which a government steps in and removes or repairs a property condition that is harming neighbors or the surrounding the community, often when the owner cannot or will not act.
State law establishes when and how local governments may enter properties to abate nuisance conditions. Common actions include boarding and securing vacant properties’ windows and doors, demolishing unsafe structures, mowing high weeds and grass, and removing trash and debris. State law also prescribes how governments recoup the public dollars spent, most often in the form of a lien. The most effective state statutes for nuisance abatement allow for such a lien to have “priority” over all other liens against the property, similar to the priority lien status usually accorded to unpaid property tax liens. This priority lien status means, in part, that if the local government chooses to foreclose on the lien, it gets paid first out of the proceeds of any sale of the property. This gives the owner a powerful incentive to either pay the local government back or risk the loss of the property.
Nuisance abatement addresses a property’s immediate harm and keeps them from spreading along a corridor. On its own, however, it does not position a property for reuse or advance the corridor’s broader goals. That requires continued engagement with property owners, incentives, and other financing to transition to reuse. In the right circumstances, the cost of abatement can also be recouped through the delinquent tax enforcement process or through code lien foreclosure.
Key Questions
- Do state and local laws give the local government the authority to address common nuisance conditions (e.g., secure or board buildings, remove debris, mow overgrown lots, make emergency repairs, demolish unsafe structures)?
- Can the local government recover abatement costs through a priority lien, the tax bill, or another mechanism? Does the local government have a realistic path to collect those costs?
- What happens after the nuisance is addressed? Is there a plan for continued owner engagement, enforcement, acquisition, or other interventions to keep the property from returning to the same condition and move it toward reuse?
Delinquent Property Tax Enforcement
The local government’s authority to enforce nonpayment of the property tax lien, or “delinquent property tax enforcement,” is a powerful tool for addressing vacancy and deterioration. When designed and implemented effectively, delinquent property tax enforcement can create a pathway to transfer properties from owners who are unwilling or unable to maintain them to new, responsible owners who can return them to productive use.
In weaker markets, owners often abandon their property responsibilities, including the payment of property taxes, because the cost of compliance outweighs the property’s value. However, communities report that vacant commercial properties may be less likely than vacant homes to become tax delinquent, in part because commercial properties tend to have higher values. As a result, owners may remain current on property taxes even when a property is vacant. Commercial properties may also carry private liens tied to financing that enabled acquisition, renovations, or the purchase of business equipment. Lenders may pay outstanding taxes to protect their interests or pursue their own lengthy foreclosure processes. For these reasons, tax foreclosure can be a less viable intervention point for commercial properties.
In these situations, it becomes even more important that the fully loaded costs of staff time spent on code enforcement and necessary nuisance abatement activities be calculated and added to the tax bill. At the very least, taxpayers will then likely get reimbursed for this critical investment in public safety.
In other cases, local governments may have the authority to pursue tax foreclosure but choose not to because of the financial, legal, or operational liabilities of acquiring and managing commercial properties should the property not sell at a foreclosure auction. Local government decision makers must therefore understand how common commercial tax delinquency is and how their enforcement process works. They should also ask whether a corridor strategy with the right partners at the table changes how they assess risk. These assessments show whether delinquent property tax enforcement is a viable pathway or whether other tools are needed.
Although its utility to compel the transfer of vacant commercial properties to new ownership may be limited, this tool is still worth exploring.
Community Progress advocates for two policy approaches that focus on resolving property-related issues rather than penalizing the owner personally:
Focus on Foreclosure: Selling tax liens to private investors, or expending limited public resources going after property owners for personal payment of the debt (which is especially challenging for properties owned by a single-asset LLC), is inefficient and prolongs the time the property sits vacant, deteriorating further.
Instead, focus on developing a judicially supervised foreclosure process that gives the owner a defined date by which to pay all outstanding amounts. If not paid, it then results in an in rem judgment (against the property, not the individual owner) allowing the property to be sold at a court-ordered public sale. If the property does not sell, it is then transferred to the foreclosing governmental unit. This can resolve the tax delinquency while establishing clear ownership and control over future use. For strategic corridor intervention, public control of a property can be critical to achieving the corridor strategy (see Public Ownership).
Reduce Redemption Periods for Vacant Properties: Some states have reduced the time in which an owner can redeem (pay back the unpaid taxes to prevent foreclosure) or created an expedited foreclosure processes for properties that meet statutory definitions of vacant or abandoned. These provisions recognize that a vacant, deteriorating property may warrant a different timeline than an occupied one, helping move it toward reuse more quickly. Ideally, tax foreclosure results in clear, marketable title that can be transferred to a new, responsible owner, which could include public ownership.
Key Questions
- How common is commercial tax delinquency? Are enough vacant or deteriorated commercial properties becoming delinquent for tax foreclosure to be a useful tool?
- Does state law provide a clear, effective path to tax foreclosure? What are the timelines and notice requirements, and can the process move chronically delinquent properties toward new ownership?
- Does state law allow judicial in rem foreclosure, with a court-ordered public sale and, if no bids are received at the sale, a transfer to a government entity? Does the transfer result in clear, marketable title?
- Does state law provide a reduced redemption period for vacant properties? If so, could it help move severely distressed commercial properties through foreclosure more efficiently?
- Can the local government handle the financial, environmental, legal, and property management risks of acquiring commercial properties? Could a land bank or another public entity serve that role?
- Is there a strategy for properties acquired through tax foreclosure? Is there a clear path to rehabilitation, redevelopment, or transfer to a responsible owner?
Code Lien Foreclosure
When a particularly harmful vacant or deteriorated commercial property is current on its taxes or is simply caught up in an inefficient system, code lien foreclosure may provide an alternative mechanism for moving the property into responsible ownership.
In states where local governments have limited tools for enforcing delinquent property taxes—or where systems reform is politically difficult—some communities seek to foreclose code enforcement or nuisance abatement liens, noting this tool is far more successful when those liens are given priority lien status in state law.
These laws allow certain code enforcement and abatement costs, along with other eligible expenses, to be secured by liens that receive priority similar to property tax liens, placing them ahead of most other liens. This priority can improve the likelihood that local governments will recover eligible costs when a property is sold. In many states, local governments are also authorized to foreclose on these liens, though the procedures and practical use of foreclosure vary. Some state laws authorize certain jurisdictions specific processes for foreclosing on these liens to address harmful vacant properties. When properly structured and implemented, these processes can help local governments overcome competing claims against a property and facilitate its transfer to responsible ownership, including public ownership when appropriate.
Key Questions
- Can code liens take priority over other liens? Without sufficient priority, the local government may be unable to recover its costs or use foreclosure effectively to move the property toward responsible ownership.
- What costs can the lien secure (i.e., fines, inspections, legal costs, emergency repairs, demolition, and other costs associated with addressing the property)?
- Does the process allow the local government to foreclose on the property, force a sale, and extinguish subordinate liens?
- Is code lien foreclosure a realistic tool? Are there enough problem properties to justify the legal, administrative, and financial resources this approach requires?
Receivership
Receivership can be a powerful tool to rehabilitate vacant property with dangerous health and safety conditions, but it requires a significant commitment of time and resources and is not appropriate for every property.
The legal process of receivership allows a municipality or, where authorized by state law, an interested party, such as a tenant, a neighbor, or a qualified nonprofit, to petition a court to request the appointment of a receiver when an owner has failed to address serious code violations or dangerous conditions. If the court grants the petition, it appoints a receiver—typically a property management company, developer, nonprofit, attorney, or other qualified entity—to take control of the property and oversee its rehabilitation or sale. (In Pennsylvania, this legal process is referred to as conservatorship rather than receivership.)
Once appointed, the receiver may be authorized to secure and manage the property, borrow or spend funds to address code violations and rehabilitate the building, and place a lien on the property to recover those costs. The most successful receivership statutes allow the receiver’s lien to take priority over all other liens, except municipal taxes. This is crucial to the success of the receivership because it allows receivers to recover costs even when there is a mortgage or other lien on the property. Depending on state law and circumstances, the original owner or interest-holder may regain control by reimbursing the receiver, or the property may be sold or transferred to a responsible owner.
Receivership can preserve and restore vacant buildings at risk of demolition-by-neglect and address dangerous health and safety conditions. In states where nonprofits or other entities can petition for the appointment of a receiver, receivership can also be a tool that allows mission-aligned entities to take on some of the remediation efforts, freeing up municipal capacity to tackle other issues. But success depends on there being a receiver capable of funding the costs of repairs, maintenance, and management and enough value in the property to cover these costs if the owner does not repay them.
As with other code enforcement tools, the goal of receivership is compliance with local and state health and safety laws. In many cases, this result is achieved through a settlement with the owner and a court-supervised process in which the owner remediates the dangerous conditions at the property. This result is as successful as the appointment of a receiver.
State laws vary in their authorization of receivership, with some states explicitly permitting it, others relying on the courts’ equitable authority, and some providing no clear pathway. Even where receivership is authorized, statutes may limit its application to residential properties. However, some states allow receivership of commercial and mixed-use properties, either explicitly or through judicial authority. California, for example, permits commercial property receivership, and receivers have successfully rehabilitated commercial spaces, bringing new vibrancy to downtown communities. Regardless of the approach, having explicit statutory authority, as in Tennessee or Pennsylvania, provides a stronger and more reliable legal foundation.
Key Questions
- Does state law permit receivership for vacant commercial properties?
- Is the building a realistic candidate? Can it be rehabilitated, and is that economically feasible given local market conditions and available resources, including potential grant funding?
- Does the receiver’s lien have priority status? Can the receiver borrow funds for the rehabilitation against the property? Will the receivership action result in clear title after the sale of the property?
- Does state law provide a clear exit strategy? Can the receiver recover its costs or transfer the property to responsible ownership after rehabilitation?
Eminent Domain
Eminent domain is a legal process that lets local governments or their designated agencies, like redevelopment authorities, take a property from a private owner for a specific public purpose, which could include redeveloping disinvested areas. The acquiring agency must compensate the property owner, under the process outlined in state law. While eminent domain is a powerful tool, it can be a complex legal process that requires a significant amount of public resources to administer.
Communities may be hesitant to use eminent domain because it was historically wielded as a redevelopment tool to intentionally displace Black residents. Between 1950 and 1966, the federal government funneled money to municipalities across the country to clear “blighted” or “slum” neighborhoods, with the intended goal of creating better housing. In reality, this disproportionately displaced families of color, and often physically (and intentionally) perpetuated segregation. It is essential to keep this history in mind if considering using eminent domain in specific circumstances as an intervention of last resort.
Key Questions
- Is eminent domain necessary? Have other approaches like tax or code lien foreclosure been tried or considered, and is acquisition through eminent domain warranted given the circumstances?
- Is there a realistic path to reuse after acquisition? Does the public entity have a clear plan, funding, and potential end user for the property?
- Are there resources and legal capacity to acquire the property, provide required compensation, and carry the property through to redevelopment?